I'm interested in the reaction of some Ham and High staff to the publication of a BNP ad in their paper. Their point that they do not want the BNP's cash to be paying their wages is completely legitimate and I understand why they do not want to give credibility to the organisation by advertising it. However, in a democracy that is supposedly for free speech it is interesting that we will only let speak the people who agree with us.
Geoff Martin, the editor of the H&H seems to agree and wrote on page 4, "To be able to tolerate those we vehemently disagree with is the hallmark of an open, egalitarian and democratic society, where freedom of speech and expression are sacrosanct."
So why do journalists, who prize the freedom of speech above anything else, want to suppress it? The staff of a local paper I worked at over Christmas once refused to send their pages to the printer until an advert for the BNP had been removed.
I understand their objections to the organisation, objections that I too share, but these objections seem to be more important to them than the sanctity of free speech. The idea that there are degrees of what it is ok to say is slightly alarming. I''m not sure Voltaire would approve.
Thursday, 10 April 2008
Gordon Brown + malaria crisis = American Idol
The weirdest story of the day has to be this. I'm not convinced anyone involved knew the audience of American Idol. When Brown's Scottish accent started booming about the plight of malaria-ridden African children I'm reasonably confident the most common reaction was "Wha'?" or maybe "Huh?" The newly hired PR in charge of stopping Gordon looking like a wally must have been on a tea break.
Wednesday, 9 April 2008
Commitment's a dirty word
The moment in The Apprentice when the absolute spanner of a team leader, Ian, demanded they go round the table so his team could proclaim their allegiance to him and their determination to win a treat from SirAlan will go down in team-building history.
The fact this suggestion was not greeted with scoffs but declarations they would offer 110% commitment was equally mirth-worthy.
In fact there was no limit to the treats tonight's gripping installment had in store. The idea that Italian pub grub should be served with false moustaches and Italian accents was hailed as genius, the plan only tripped up when the minute-taker couldn't spell 'accents'. It was ok though, his comrades knew what he meant.
The stripping 'Bollywood' dancer was a feast for the eyes, as was the sight of fascist ex-team leader Jenny going to beserk with uncontained delight at the sight.
It is pleasing to me that SirAlan seems to be methodically firing the boys with the worst hair cuts so maybe the finalists will all be thick as two short planks but will look like Toni and Guy models. One can only hope.
The fact this suggestion was not greeted with scoffs but declarations they would offer 110% commitment was equally mirth-worthy.
In fact there was no limit to the treats tonight's gripping installment had in store. The idea that Italian pub grub should be served with false moustaches and Italian accents was hailed as genius, the plan only tripped up when the minute-taker couldn't spell 'accents'. It was ok though, his comrades knew what he meant.
The stripping 'Bollywood' dancer was a feast for the eyes, as was the sight of fascist ex-team leader Jenny going to beserk with uncontained delight at the sight.
It is pleasing to me that SirAlan seems to be methodically firing the boys with the worst hair cuts so maybe the finalists will all be thick as two short planks but will look like Toni and Guy models. One can only hope.
Monday, 7 April 2008
Wealthy and connected?
Peter Wilby's rant in today's MediaGuardian arguing that journalism is a profession for the wealthy and connected seems a little skewed.
He makes the legitimate point that to be able to forge a career in the media some kind of expensive postgraduate qualification is necessary. As a result, it excludes people who cannot afford the fees. He also argues that the work experience so crucial to advancement is the preserve of people living in and around London or those who can afford to pay for somewhere to stay and outlines the supposed small pool of universities from which students on my course are taken.
While there are a number from Oxford, Cambridge, Bristol and Leeds there are also people from Exeter, St Andrews, Manchester, UCL, Imperial, Durham and Lancashire. His argument that we are not representative of the population because these universities take people from fee-paying schools is misguided. While a number did go to private or public schools, they were all selective, meaning they were already deemed clever enough to meet the standards of the establishment. It makes sense they would then go on to good universities and get places on competitive postgraduate courses.
His argument that courses such as the one I am undertaking are the privilege of the wealthy is undermined by his own employer.
The Scott Trust, which owns the Guardian, is paying the fees of three of my colleagues who might not otherwise be able to cover the expense. Not only that but the trust sets them up with work experience at papers such as the Guardian, Observer and MEN and pays accommodation costs over the holidays.
In addition, I was given funding by the Chancellor of my undergraduate university and a number of other colleagues have funding from the AHRC and have bank loans.
Every single person at City has worked incredibly hard to be there and forge a career for themselves in a highly competitive and ruthless industry. We have already competed to get on the course and this experience has set us up to carry on competing for jobs and promotions and whatever else comes our way.
Such a narrow minded view of his own profession shows Wilby as a man keen to see the worst in his successors, instead of supporting and encouraging those entering the industry at such a precarious time.
He makes the legitimate point that to be able to forge a career in the media some kind of expensive postgraduate qualification is necessary. As a result, it excludes people who cannot afford the fees. He also argues that the work experience so crucial to advancement is the preserve of people living in and around London or those who can afford to pay for somewhere to stay and outlines the supposed small pool of universities from which students on my course are taken.
While there are a number from Oxford, Cambridge, Bristol and Leeds there are also people from Exeter, St Andrews, Manchester, UCL, Imperial, Durham and Lancashire. His argument that we are not representative of the population because these universities take people from fee-paying schools is misguided. While a number did go to private or public schools, they were all selective, meaning they were already deemed clever enough to meet the standards of the establishment. It makes sense they would then go on to good universities and get places on competitive postgraduate courses.
His argument that courses such as the one I am undertaking are the privilege of the wealthy is undermined by his own employer.
The Scott Trust, which owns the Guardian, is paying the fees of three of my colleagues who might not otherwise be able to cover the expense. Not only that but the trust sets them up with work experience at papers such as the Guardian, Observer and MEN and pays accommodation costs over the holidays.
In addition, I was given funding by the Chancellor of my undergraduate university and a number of other colleagues have funding from the AHRC and have bank loans.
Every single person at City has worked incredibly hard to be there and forge a career for themselves in a highly competitive and ruthless industry. We have already competed to get on the course and this experience has set us up to carry on competing for jobs and promotions and whatever else comes our way.
Such a narrow minded view of his own profession shows Wilby as a man keen to see the worst in his successors, instead of supporting and encouraging those entering the industry at such a precarious time.
Sunday, 6 April 2008
Miss Independent
I did some freelance work at the Independent on Sunday last week and am posting the links here. The delectable selection includes the NAO's report on HMRC, the struggle the middle classes face to survive the credit crunch, the decline in customer satisfaction in home phone companies and the virtue in choosing consistently strong savings accounts. Wait with bated breath for the feature next weekend on parents who take out insurance in case they have twins.
Monday, 31 March 2008
Byline + Brooker = Bliss
The last piece I wrote for the Guardian is in today and I am thrilled to see it leading the section. I am equally delighted by the return of Charlie Brooker in G2. He has been away for the last few weeks and so I have lived a life of misery. If his columns are anything to go by, so has he.
His page-long rant about the new series of the Apprentice confirms my new conviction that it is officially OK to talk about my guilty pleasure.
Every single paper I read last Thursday contained a lengthy post-mortem on the first agonising hour of the genius series and I hope they will continue to do so. While shows like Big Brother ceased to contain any social commentary merit when they became lengthy audtion tapes for Simon Fuller, the Apprentice is a fascinating insight into the mind of the seriously deluded. Titbits such as "The spoken word is my tool" and "I am the best salesperson in Europe" have already been touted as examples of the candidates egomania but there was also comedy gold when Raef defended himself for labelling the fish wrong. For every mistake I make from now on I will say "At least I didn't label a shark a hamster" and the greatest wits in Christendom will be stumped for a response.
His page-long rant about the new series of the Apprentice confirms my new conviction that it is officially OK to talk about my guilty pleasure.
Every single paper I read last Thursday contained a lengthy post-mortem on the first agonising hour of the genius series and I hope they will continue to do so. While shows like Big Brother ceased to contain any social commentary merit when they became lengthy audtion tapes for Simon Fuller, the Apprentice is a fascinating insight into the mind of the seriously deluded. Titbits such as "The spoken word is my tool" and "I am the best salesperson in Europe" have already been touted as examples of the candidates egomania but there was also comedy gold when Raef defended himself for labelling the fish wrong. For every mistake I make from now on I will say "At least I didn't label a shark a hamster" and the greatest wits in Christendom will be stumped for a response.
Friday, 28 March 2008
What a Darling
My week with Larry Elliott took me to the Treasury yesterday to interview the Chancellor. Larry received a summons in the morning and in the afternoon we trotted off to Westminster keen to hear the news that Darling was clearly keen to impart. After a bit of a wait while he was ferried back from the Brown/Sarkozy extended photocall at the Emirates, we were ushered in for our audience.
Having only ever seen Mr Darling on TV, I had to suppress my childish urge to stare at the famous eyebrows. He was charm personified though and gave Larry a great story about new legislation to introduce US style plea-bargaining laws for City bad boys who manipulate the markets. The piece is today's splash.
I've also clocked up another shared by-line with a depressing-but-interesting piece about consumer confidence.
I spent this morning at Centre Point at a CBI press briefing to hear even more about how the economy is going to hell and we should probably all just give up now. There will potentially be huge job losses and confidence in the financial services sector is plummeting. Hopefully the piece will lead the section on Monday.
Having only ever seen Mr Darling on TV, I had to suppress my childish urge to stare at the famous eyebrows. He was charm personified though and gave Larry a great story about new legislation to introduce US style plea-bargaining laws for City bad boys who manipulate the markets. The piece is today's splash.
I've also clocked up another shared by-line with a depressing-but-interesting piece about consumer confidence.
I spent this morning at Centre Point at a CBI press briefing to hear even more about how the economy is going to hell and we should probably all just give up now. There will potentially be huge job losses and confidence in the financial services sector is plummeting. Hopefully the piece will lead the section on Monday.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)